Three Frameworks for Crypto Accounting
How Each Framework Treats Crypto Assets
| Treatment Area | IFRS (IAS 38) | US GAAP (Post-ASU 2023-08) | UK GAAP (FRS 102) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classification | Intangible asset (most cases) or inventory (IAS 2 for trading businesses) | Intangible asset — qualifying crypto subject to new ASU | Intangible asset at cost |
| Initial recognition | Cost (purchase price + directly attributable costs) | Cost (historical); fair value going forward for qualifying | Cost |
| Subsequent measurement | Cost model (cost less impairment) OR revaluation (if active market) | Fair value — changes through net income (qualifying assets) | Cost less impairment (no revaluation) |
| Impairment | IAS 36 — impairment when carrying value > recoverable amount | No separate impairment test — fair value changes flow to P&L | FRS 102 Section 27 — impairment |
| Price recovery | Can reverse impairment if revaluation model used (OCI); not under cost model | Yes — fair value increases recognised in net income | Cannot reverse impairment |
| Disclosures | IAS 38 disclosures + IFRS 7 risk disclosures | Roll-forward table, significant holdings, key assumptions | FRS 102 basic disclosures |
| Effective for | All IFRS reporters (immediate) | Public entities: fiscal years after Dec 15, 2024 | UK entities for periods from Jan 1, 2026 |
Which Framework to Apply
The applicable framework is primarily determined by your jurisdiction and investor base — it is not a free choice in most cases. Here is how to identify which standard applies:
US GAAP: Mandatory for US SEC registrants (public companies listed on US exchanges), companies filing with the SEC, and US companies raising from US institutional investors (who typically require US GAAP financials). US private companies may defer ASU 2023-08 until fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2025.
IFRS: Required for listed companies in the EU, UK, Australia, Singapore, Canada (listed), and 140+ other countries. Also commonly used by non-listed companies in these jurisdictions, international businesses, and companies seeking to raise from non-US institutional investors.
UK GAAP (FRS 102): Applied by UK non-listed entities — UK subsidiaries, private companies, and non-SEC reporting entities incorporated in England and Wales, Scotland, or Northern Ireland. FRS 102 is closer to IFRS than US GAAP.
Impact of FASB ASU 2023-08
FASB ASU 2023-08, issued in December 2023, represents the most significant change to US GAAP accounting for crypto assets since crypto became a mainstream corporate treasury item. Under the old model, companies recognised impairment when crypto prices fell but could NOT write assets back up when prices recovered. This created a ratchet effect where long-term holders accumulated growing impairment charges on their balance sheets.
Under ASU 2023-08, qualifying crypto assets are measured at fair value at each reporting date, with ALL changes — gains and losses — recognised in net income. This means corporate Bitcoin holders will see their income statements move significantly with Bitcoin price volatility. Companies like MicroStrategy (now Strategy), Tesla, and Block (Square) are materially affected by this change.
The standard requires enhanced disclosures: a roll-forward table showing beginning balance, additions, disposals, fair value changes, and ending balance for each type of qualifying crypto asset; and qualitative disclosure about any significant crypto holdings and associated risks.